Endurance search
Lesson Date : 2019-03-04

토론주제 : Will the wreck of the Endurance ever be found?

                             
토론기간 : 2019-03-04 ~ 2019-04-04
토론이용안내: 1.찬성,반대 중 선택>> 반론참여 버튼생성>>반론참여 클릭>>텍스트 입력, 음성녹음, 동영상등록 중 선택 의견을 남기세요.
                        2.반대 의견의 상대방 지목 은 최대 3명까지 가능하며, 반론에 대한 답글은 제한이 없습니다.
No. 0
Manager's Pro Opinion
Yes, the wreck of the Endurance will be found. There are accurate records of Shackleton’s expedition. Scientists know exactly where the ship sank. Therefore, if the sea ice conditions are favorable, the search for the ship should be successful. It will not be easy, but it is not impossible. Today, scientists can use underwater robots to survey and film large areas of the seabed. The technology these robots are fitted with will continue to advance and become even more efficient.
No. 0
Manager's Con Opinion
No, the wreck of the Endurance will never be found. Exploring the Antarctic seabed is very difficult. For the search to be successful, the area needs to be completely free of sea ice. Scientists have already used the latest technology to look for the ship. Yet, they still failed. Finding the money to pay for an icebreaker to visit the Weddell Sea is another problem. These difficulties mean that finding the remains of the Endurance on the seafloor is likely to be impossible.

토론 시작

No. 5030

Yes, I think the wreck of the Endurance will be found. Technology is always developing. The Endurance will be found eventually. The scientists know exactly where the ship sank. They could use underwater robots to find the ship. If they found wreck of the Endurance, the historical value would be high. So, they will keep trying to find the Endurance.

()19.03.05 19:05

No. 5039

I think it wll be never found. Because, we know where did the ship sank but, it's hard to find something under the ice. Like the scientist try to find the ship with new technolege, but they couldn't find the ship. And they were almost in same situation as the Endurancewas. So I think it will be never found.

이윤서(clairelee)19.03.10 20:37

No. 5040

Even if the technologe had gotten more better, there could be a bad situation such as they got trap by ice.

이윤서(clairelee)19.03.10 20:40

No. 5041

Scientist know where the ship sank, yes I agree with that, and technology is keep developing. But the place where the ship sank isn't a good place where we can find the wreck of it. It's similar place where the Titanic sank. It's realy hard to found it. like the news paper said, they lost signer of the underwater robot. It could happen again and again.

이윤서(clairelee)19.03.10 20:46

No. 5042

It could be impossible, if the ice keep getting around where scientist's boat is. And the ship has sank 104 years ago. the ship might have broken in to many piecies. You don't know if the new technology can help to find the Endurance.

이윤서(clairelee)19.03.10 20:51

No. 5054

If the technology develops enough to find the ship, the scientists could find the ship. An iceboat can broke the ice easily.

()19.03.12 20:45

No. 5055

I want to give an example for this one. The Apollo project succeed when they tried 11 times. They didn't give up 10 times they failed. We can send a highly efficient robot to find the ship. Also, we can find out the problem of the robot when it fails . We can make the next robot can't malfunction.

()19.03.12 21:01

No. 5073

We can make a device that can find the ship with new technology. You don't know what can be possible with new technology. I agree the ship might be broken, but we need to find it and put the pieces together if that ever happened. The ship belonged to Sir Ernest Shackleton. He is a person who saved all of his Antarctic expedition members.
That is a great achievement. We need to find the ship to admire the work he has done.

()19.03.13 20:49

No. 5089

For me I think it is possible. Since for the past century we searched many sunken ships. And our technology is getting better it is possible. It might made in wood and it is in Antarctica, We can do it.

최건(bebepe33)19.03.18 18:40